The Love Diaries: The Easy Test to Find Out if the Person You’re Dating is a Narcissist (And My Real World Worst Possible Example of It…)

The ‘Occasion Theory’ is the latest dating term to go viral and can supposedly help you immediately find out if the person you’re seeing is actually a narcissist. We have experienced this first hand, and have a rather extreme version of it to share, but it seems the experts agree too, that THIS is when a narcissist can really show their true colours…

Welcome to our series, The Love Diaries – a space for you to share your experiences, advice, fairy-tale endings, setbacks and heartbreaks. We’ll be hearing from industry experts giving practical advice alongside Capsule readers (You!) sharing your firsthand experiences with love – from the woman who cheated on her husband with a work colleague, one woman’s temptation now the love of her life is finally single (although she’s not), and the woman who forced her husband to choose between her and his girlfriend. 

Do you have a story you’d like to share? Send an email to alice@capsulenz.com!

TW: Suicide / Toxic Relationships

Many, many years ago when I was working in magazines and in a different relationship, my boss called me to tell me that she had some exciting news. A big awards night was coming up and she’d just got word that I had won a pretty amazing award in a category that I’d been surprised to hear I was even nominated for in the first place.

It was a Sunday afternoon, but she insisted that I come over to her house that evening, along with my partner at the time to have a glass of Champagne with her and her husband. My boyfriend was deathly hungover, so wasn’t thrilled about leaving the house, but perked himself up enough to jump in a taxi to go over to their house.

Maybe a month later, it was time to actually go to the big awards night. My boss sprung for a make-up artist and I bought a new dress. Partners didn’t come to the awards, but there was an after party at a bar and he – plus a few other friends – were planning on meeting me there.

My memory of the awards ceremony itself are a bit hazy now, but I mostly remember it being so fun and joyous and the photos of us all that night really capture that feeling.

But then we moved to the after party.

I can remember spotting my boyfriend across the bar and immediately clocking something was wrong. He was obviously many, many drinks deep, but he also seemed very… dark. His eyes looked black. Something – I wasn’t quite sure what – was going on with him, and it was most definitely not good.

Sadly, this wasn’t all that irregular. He’d often drink a heck of a lot on a Friday night and then get into an argument with someone – preferably not me – and the night wouldn’t end well. I made the quick decision to try to stay away from him as much as I could for the rest of that night.

Whatever was going on, he was mooching around, obviously trying to get me to ask him what was wrong and I didn’t want to give in and play that game. I wanted to have one night where I let things be about me for a little while. I’d had an amazing work year, and I wanted just one night, one moment to be able to soak that in.

At some point though, I caved. I don’t remember the conversation that led to the moment, but I distinctively remember taking a deep breath, sighing and asking, “Ok. What’s going on with you? What’s wrong?”

I remember absolutely crystal clear the feelings I had right after he responded (unfortunately all these years later it’s my most vivid memory of the night). Blood started rushing through my ears so loudly it felt like the volume of the blaring music suddenly cut out. I couldn’t get my eyes to focus. I had so many thoughts and questions flood my brain at once, that my mouth felt like it was moving for a while before I started forming proper sentences and questions.

“What’s wrong?” I had asked him.

He’d paused, then looked away. ‘God he’s drunk,’ I thought to myself.

And then he said it.

“My brother killed himself today.”

I knew his brother. I loved his brother. We had become friends over the years, and I’d been sad – but excited for him – when he’d packed up and moved to the UK on his OE. And now, he was… dead?

“What? What? What are you saying?” I repeated, until a flurry of questions exploded from me. “How? When? What are we doing here?! Why are we in a bar right now when this has happened?! How did you find out? When did you find out? Why are we here?! Who found him? Does your mum know? Where is she? How is she? Why are we here?! Why aren’t we with your mum?!”

He did a lot of shrugging and sighing, and tried to answer some of my questions, but I couldn’t grasp what he was saying.

I started to feel numbness creep over me. I felt like a monster. I hadn’t wanted my partner to ‘ruin’ my night and all this time he was dealing with the worst possible situation. How could this be? How could he be dead? But whilst the room felt like it was pulsating, another little gnawing thought bubbled up in my brain. “Wait a minute. Is this really true?” it whispered.

It turned out that no, it most certainly wasn’t true. His brother was very much alive and well and going about his normal workday on the other side of the earth.

How exactly I found this out, and how long it took to figure out he was still very much alive, I can’t remember exactly anymore – but I remember he had a slew of excuses about why he’d said it. He was drunk, he was stressed, there was a lot going on, and then he wanted to quickly change the subject and move attention elsewhere.

Now, in hindsight of course it’s so painfully obvious what happened – the attention was on me that night, not him, and he just couldn’t quite handle that, so he found a way (an extremely messed up way) to get my attention back on him.

I hadn’t thought of that night in years, until I was recently reading about something called the ‘Occasion Theory’.

It’s another one of those viral Tiktok trends – this one is by a South African content creator called Bella Bennett.

Now, Bella isn’t a psychologist, but her theory is definitely based on the findings of doctors and psychiatrists – she’s just given a catchy name to it and a compelling video that’s gone viral.

She says Occasion Theory is the best and easiest way to test whether the person you’re dating is actually secretly (or not so secretly) a narcissist.

“[The] quickest way to find out if you’re dating a narcissist is when you have a special occasion coming up, whether it’s your friend’s birthday, whatever; make it anything, make it up,” Bella says.

“Watch how they treat you [in] the days, the nights, the morning, leading up to that occasion. The moment something else is making you happy, and the attention is going off of them, they can’t stand it.”

The Science Behind ‘Occasion Theory’

Suzanne Degges-White, Ph.D is a licensed counselor and professor at Northern Illinois University and long before Tiktok was even invented, talked about how narcissist behave on special occasions, and why they’re so often a time in which their true colours become obvious.

“When someone suffers from narcissistic personality disorder, or displays significant narcissistic tendencies, celebrations are often when the greatest chaos and calamity can occur,” she says.

“Narcissists don’t enjoy celebrating the milestone events of others and will try to turn the attention to themselves regardless of who the guest of honour was meant to be.”

Suzanne says narcissistic behaviour can also be very noticeable during big holidays like Christmas.

“Narcissists can be especially disruptive during holiday celebrations since there is no single rival for their attention, but an entire day, season, or event,” she says. “Narcissists feel the holiday steals the spotlight that they, themselves, should own.”

Generally two types of narcissists, says Suzanne: the grandiose and the vulnerable.

“Grandiose narcissists do everything in a big way and genuinely believe that they lead “larger than life” lives that are the envy of everyone who knows them,” she says.

“Vulnerable narcissists don’t necessarily seek as much public attention, but they demand that they are the center of attention in one-on-one relationships. When denied their narcissistic supply, they can unexpectedly lash out with surprisingly hostile and vicious aggression fuelled by narcissistic rage.”

Narcissism and Abuse – The Red Flags to Look Out For

Psychotherapist Kaytee Gillis says that big events can unearth someone’s narcissistic traits, but, there are many other red flags that on their own can be easily dismissed. Together though, they tell a different story.

Narcissism is a trait to be mindful about though, she says, as although not everyone who has narcissistic tendencies will also be cruel and abusive, but there are definitely links. They are much more likely than the general population to be aggressive when threatened or provoked in some way (Kjærvik & Bushman, 2021).

“Many find out too late that their partner has narcissistic traits, only to look back at the red flags that seemed so easily excusable at the time,” she says. “When you are in a relationship, it can feel scary to realize that your partner lacks empathy and compassion, and many worry that their partner’s behaviors will get worse if they try to leave.”

She says that the biggest red flag to look out for that you may be with someone who shows signs of narcissistic abuse, is cruelty without remorse. But there are many others.

Here, she shares five of the biggest red flags to watch out for:

  1. Do they make fun of you or others in a cruel, mean way? This would be more than consensual teasing in some relationships where the behaviour is acceptable to both partners. Cruel bullying is a sign of limited or no empathy.
  2. Do they think that all mistakes are someone else’s fault? In isolation, this could be immaturity or arrogance. But it could also make them incapable of owning their part in a relationship ending and give them a false sense of being wronged.
  3. Do they lie a lot, or say things constantly that just do not add up or do not make sense? Everyone tells white lies but look out for constant deceit.
  4. Do they show very little capacity for remorse or self-reflection? This could be a clue that they might not handle the breakup in a healthy way or that they will be unable to handle rejection
  5. Do they threaten to ruin your career or reputation if you leave? Or do you notice that they say this to other people? Perhaps they threaten to ruin the career of a coworker or family member who wronged them.

The Divorce Diaries: “He Changed His Mind About Wanting Children… While I Was 7 Months Pregnant”

This week we talk to a woman who tells the story of how her 'husband left when I was pregnant' - seven months pregnant! In...

The Divorce Diaries: “Should I Stay in My Marriage For the Sake Of Our Kids?”

Linda* knows her marriage is done, but she's currently too afraid to leave. She's worried about her kids and divorce - what affect will...

Are You & Your Partner Aligned, Financially? The Curve’s Vic Harris Breaks Down How You Can Stop Money Matters From Causing a Break Up

The Curve's Vic Harris has spent a decade working deep in people's finances - first as a fund manager, then building a financial education...

The Motherhood Diaries: The Shame, Pain & Misconceptions Around Breastfeeding, Pumping & Formula Feeding

It seems however a new mother ends up feeding her baby (regardless of whether that method ends up being her choice or not), someone...