Are the election promises currently being thrown around attention-grabbing soundbites rather than evidence-based policies? And how are policies are born? Sarah Lang looks into it.

Three free GP visits a year (Labour). Free prescriptions for all, scrapping the $5 fee (Labour). Cutting 10% of eligible student-loan balances (Labour). Capping weekly public-transport costs at $20 in Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch, and $10 in regions (Labour).
New police powers to disperse gangs (National). Random drug testing for those on the jobseeker benefit (National). Higher rates rebate for seniors to help them stay in their own homes as council rates climb (National). Expand access to the government’s low-deposit scheme to buy first homes (National).
Free dental care for everyone (Greens.) Make public transport free for children, students, apprentices, community-services card holders and mobility users, with a $2 cap for everyone else (Greens).
Remove tax on KiwiSaver earnings, also scrapping government contributions (ACT). Increase the proportion of the health budget spent on Pharmac by one percent a year, to publicly fund more medicines/treatment (ACT).
Increase the minimum wage by at least inflation levels every year (NZ First).
Scrap GST from all food and non-alcoholic drinks (Te Pāti Māori).
A Citizen’s Income so everyone can afford the basics, a Land Value Tax to lower house prices, and Kiwisaver 2.0: a compulsory superannuation system (The Opportunity Party).
These are a few of the policy promises being made by New Zealand political parties right now, and I’m not necessarily including the most important ones, nor saying which I think are good and badideas. I’m just opening a Party Pack of lollies.
Suddenly we’re hearing all these things that sound just dandy! How do politicians suddenly know how to change our lives for the better? Have they been hibernating over winter? Or is this a lolly scramble?
The Birth of Policies
When looking at how policies are born, we must first make a key distinction. Within the executive branch of government – which runs the country and makes decisions on what New Zealand should spend its money on – public servants are asked to come up with policy advice, which is then considered by ministers.
But political parties coming out with policies or promises as an election looms – well, that’s another thing entirely. Are they assessing what could really improve a certain area of concern (e.g. crime)? Or are they just going with sound-bites and hoping the rest will work itself out later on?
Dr Jaimie Monk is a public-policy researcher at Motu Research: an independent economics and policy research institute focused on the public good. I asked her how the political parties may come up with their policies.
Jaimie says the process is different for each party, but they may run prospective policies past consultants and/or focus groups. “For politicians, when deciding on policy, there’s always a tension between policy development and party politics – between what the evidence says will work, and what’s likely to win votes. During the build-up to an election, it certainly appears that the latter is driving a lot of the policy decision-making.”
Bribe Time?
I feel like parties are throwing stuff at the wall and seeing what sticks – and throwing out promises that can be summarised in a sentence. “That’s exactly what they’re doing,” Jaimie says. “To win votes, they’re promising to do whatever they think is popular.”
Election-season bribery, or ‘eye-catching policies’?
“I’d tend more towards calling it bribery at this point,” Jaimie says, “or at least headlining what they think will be most popular”.
“You’ve got politicians trying to win votes and most of us are pretty present-biased. We tend to take $100 now versus $125 in a year’s time.” This ‘present bias’, a concept that fits within behavioural economics, is our inclination to choose a smaller reward in the present instead of a larger reward in the future. And that makes total sense.
Perception is Key
“Policy is a lot to do with how things are perceived rather than how they actually are,” Jaimie says. “There’s this classic quote about The Lamppost Theory of Economic Policy: that politicians use economics, or evidence in general, like drunks use lampposts, for support but not really for illumination.”
Has Jaimie noticed that parties sometimes water down policies, or backtrack on them, once they’re in government?
“Totally. You could take it cynically or not. Sometimes it was about just trying to get votes, but sometimes it’s politicians initially being overly optimistic about things – and encountering reality once they’re elected, or having to work with other parties in MMP. Or it’s about misjudging the cost or the practicalities of what it actually takes to roll something out.”
After all, we can’t forget there’s no such thing as a free lunch. This is ‘opportunity cost’: when you spend money on something, you can’t spend it on something else. “The pot is limited.”
Executive Suite
When a government is in power, how are policies born?
I got some insight into this when I did a postgraduate public-policy paper called Policy Methods & Practise at Victoria University.
For an assignment, as a (pretend) policy adviser for the Minister of Corrections, my ‘Evidence Question’ to answer was “what is known about the benefits and drawbacks of creative-arts programmes in prisons?”.
I found different pieces of evidence (primarily, journal articles). Then I assessed and rated the quality of these against key criteria I chose, including the reputation of the author and publication, the recency, location and design of the study, the contribution to knowledge of the wider research area, the risk of bias, and well-supported conclusions without over-reach.
So I learned about what should happen, in a way that would theoretically weed out the bad ideas, and illuminate the good ones. But is this common practise?
Jaimie is somewhat reassuring. “There are a lot of great people in the public sector in Wellington doing good work. Their job is to be impartial, provide advice and research for these things [prospective policies], and take it to the minister for big decisions. Then the minister weighs up both ‘is this going to work’ and political considerations.”
Political considerations – as in how the public may react? “Yes, but also how the policy fits with the direction of their party and coalition parties etc. There’s a strong incentive not to cause any unnecessary negative media attention, so risk aversion plays a role in decision-making too.”
Are some policies left like embryos in a petri dish, and never birthed? “I’m sure there are,” Jaimie says. “There are ideas thrown around all the time and some things will get well developed then frequently shelved at the last minute, usually for political considerations.”
Back to the Future
In my course, we looked at the concept of ‘Futures Thinking’. Obviously, no one can predict the future accurately. But not thinking about the future simply doesn’t cut it, policy-wise. So, faced with the big challenges of uncertainty and complexity – and also ambiguity and volatility – how might we consider what could happen in the future, and also consider how certain techniques can inform how a policy should be enacted?
For example, you could use the approach of Backcasting (working backwards from a desired future to create a timeline of actions), Scenarios (imagining alternative plausible futures, not predicting but asking ‘what if?’), and Horizon-scanning (identifying and monitoring emerging trends that might affect or disrupt policy).
There’s also Delphi (consulting with experts to gather opinion and prioritise issues), Visioning (identifying a vision, and the steps you need to take to get there), and Volitions (taking into account people’s pre-existing values, and world views).
How much Futures Thinking is happening? Ideally, plenty.
The Policy Project sits within the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, and aims to “equip policy practitioners, teams and agencies with tools, information and advice to develop their skills and capability”. The Policy Project’s Policy Skills Framework describes the Futures Thinking skills that policy practitioners need, while the Development Pathways Tool identifies practical actions that policy practitioners can take to build these skills.
The Policy Project supports agencies to deliver their Long-term Insights Briefings, “which required the public service to look over the horizon, for the common good”. So yep, thinking about the future.
The Public Service Amendment Act 2026 changed the model for Long-term Insights Briefings. Now the DPMC will work with public-service agencies to determine the topic and content of the first briefing. The new approach is intended to enable a more integrated examination of issues of national significance and strengthen public debate about New Zealand’s future.
Evaluation
But there’s no way to know much Futures Thinking is actually happening, not how much evaluation is going on.
Jaimie says shortcuts are often taken when it comes to evaluation. “There’s very little reassessment: as in, checking if a policy that has been implemented works as intended. Evaluation is meant to inform future policy creation, but in a practical sense, there’s very little incentive for anyone to find out if something went right or wrong.”
But with the election looming (gosh, November 7 is coming up fast), we can do some policy evaluation ourselves. These sites make it easier to dip into, or do a deep dive, on policies.
- Compare the parties, candidates and policies at policy.nz; you can even look at a list of policies by topic while initially keeping the party proposing them hidden.
- The NZ Politics Promise Trapper is currently tracking 148 promises, policies and public claims across all major parties.
- This site shows policies, promises, donations, and latest polls.
I’ll be looking into one area per day – starting with health – with my morning coffee.
_______________
About the Author:


